Wingspan Review – Birds of a Feather play together

by | Mar 26, 2022 | Reviews, Board Game Reviews

  • Number of plays: 10
  • Designer: Elizabeth Hargrave
  • Artists: Ana Maria Martinez Jaramillo, Natalia Rojas, Beth Sobel
  • Release Year: 2019
  • Mechanics: Card Drafting, Dice Rolling, Hand Management, Engine Building
  • Publisher: Stonemaier Games

Introduction

Hoo-boy, talk about a sleeper hit. I remember so much drama when Wingspan was first released by Stonemaier Games in 2019. It hit store shelves and immediately sold out. Everyone wanted to get their hands on the hot new bird game, to the point where nasty rumors of ‘artificial scarcity’ began to circulate and people criticized Stonemaier Games for having poor forecasting. The reality of the situation was that no one could have predicted just how successful Wingspan would become.

How to Play

Wingspan begins each player with an empty ecosystem board, 5 bird cards, 2 goals, and 5 food (one of each type). Players can keep as many birds from their initial draw as they wish, but they need to sacrifice 1 food for each card kept.

On your turn you may place one of your cubes in any one of the four action spots on your player board, simultaneously helping keep track of how many turns in the round, and helping you remember how to run your engine.

The first possible action is to play a bird card. From your hand, simply pay the required food from your personal supply back to the bank and place your bird on one of the three ecosystems on your board (Woodlands, Plains, and Wetlands). Your bird card must go in the leftmost empty column, and depending on the column you may also need to pay an egg.

If you choose not to play a bird, You can instead play your cube in one of your three ecosystems. Each ecosystem will net you different benefits. If you place your cube in the woodland area, you’ll get to generate food based off the die on the table. The Plains allows you to lay eggs on your bird cards, and the Wetlands allow you to draw cards. As you play birds to an ecosystems, choosing to play your cube there becomes more lucrative. When you take any of the actions that correspond to the ecosystems you place your cube in the left most empty spot on that track. As bird cards fill up the weaker left slots, the basic action will get stronger (for example, the first woodland column generates 1 food while the right most generates 3). Not only will your action be better, you will also benefit from the specific bird cards that you activate as you move your cube left, completing your turn.

The charm of Wingspan lies in its great variety. The base game contains 170 individual cards, all with lovely and unique art depicting each bird. While not every card power is unique, there is still a huge variety to behold.

The game continues with players taking actions until they all run out of cubes. Players score for the goal of the round and move to the next round. After the 4th round the final score is tallied and the player with the highest score is the winner.

Review

The production of Wingspan is simply fantastic. The box and rulebook have a luxury linen finish, and the card stock for all the cards is thick and satisfying. The artwork is breathtaking, and the pastel coloured eggs are sure to give you candy cravings. Everyone I’ve shown this game to has complimented how nice everything is; it is clear that no compromises were made during production.

The game play of Wingspan is simply and straightforward. Everyone has their own goal that they’re working towards and some shared goals to help nudge players in a specific direction. The public goals generally refer to having birds in specific ecosystems, or eggs in certain types of nests, while the private goals are much more varied. Some goals will have you seeking birds with colours in their name, while others want you to amass a flock of birds with a wingspan of 76cm or less. While you only start with one of these goals, some bird cards will give you the chance to obtain more.

The bird cards are the core of Wingspan. The entire game revolves around collecting, playing, and activating the birds on your player board. Often players will find themselves grappling with the desire to activate a certain row of birds, but really needing the effects of a different action.

Over the course of a game of Wingspan you’ll likely play anywhere between 8 – 14 cards into your tableau. With 170 unique bird cards there is a great amount of variability and many paths and engines for you to explore. There is no need to do the same thing over and over again, game after game.

A game of Wingspan starts off slowly, which can be a bit painful. It takes over half of your turns of the first round to get enough food and cards to play just a couple of birds. Luckily a lot of the cards you play will give you a benefit every time they activate, making your subsequent turns more effective and allowing you to reach heights you previously thought impossible.

Personally, I’m not the biggest fan of Wingspan. It’s pleasant to look at, easy to teach and play, and offers a great amount of replayability, but I dislike how much luck is involved. The card deck, while tall and varied makes it difficult to find the specific card you need, and if one of your opponents was lucky enough to pull a food generating crow early in the game, it can be difficult to keep up. I do enjoy the small amount of positive player interaction (some cards will give all players a food, and others will give you a point when a other player takes a certain action), but I wish there were just a little more. Again, this has to do with the size of the deck and just how varied the cards are. While I know I would prefer a more focused tableau building game such as Race for the Galaxy, I recognize that the wide variety is important for the replayability of Wingspan.

But who cares about what I think – my wife absolutely LOVES Wingspan. This is one of the few games she actively asks to play, and any game that inspires a level of enthusiasm from my partner is a game that deserves applause. She loves the feeling of building an engine, she enjoys the fact that no one can throw a wrench into her mechanics and slow down her process, and she particularly enjoys when a satisfying combo can be created.

It’s also worth pointing out that the theme of birds is just plain pleasant. It’s so nice to see lovely illustrations of birds that we could see in our back yard. If Wingspan had a goblin or mountain troll theme, it would be eminently less pleasant. I think this is where Wingspan shines the brightest; it’s a fun, comforting, enjoyable experience and it is completely inoffensive. Wingspan welcomes players into the board game hobby with open wings.

4 Comments

  1. Reggie

    Awesome review! Curious to hear your thoughts after playing either of the expansions. I personally feel the European Expansion is essential and really alleviates the few complaints you had 🙂

    Reply
    • MeepleandtheMoose

      Thanks for reading! I’ll definitely seek out the European expansion if it addresses my complaints! I’m sure my wife would love more opportunities to play Wingspan some more

      Reply
  2. Joshua W

    It’s funny to look back at how the theme was initially divisive in some crusty corners of the community, yet went on to inspire/spawn an entire genre of nature themed games. I am sitting down to play this with family today and we’ll be cross referencing birdwatching books to learn even more about the birds as we play them.

    Equally amusing to note your comment that a goblin/troll theme would be less pleasant in the wake of Wyrmspan. I guess the trolls got their game in the end.

    Glad I found your site and keep up the good work. The reviews are thoughtful and definitely reflect a perspective I find valuable as a family gamer.

    Reply
    • MeepleandtheMoose

      Thanks for the kind words, I really appreciate them!

      As a gamer, I actually prefer Wyrmspan. It’s more complex, and the dragons appeal to my love of fantasy. I appreciate that it’s not just a straight re-skin, but it changes the gameplay in some interesting ways! I did show it to my partner, and her opinion was “I’d rather play with the birds”.

      The trend of beautiful, nature themed games has been helpful for me to ease more than a few new people into the hobby. Turns out Cascadia and Everdell are a more pleasent on-ramp than Castles of Burgundy and Caylus. Who knew!?

      Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Week in Review – May 18th, 2022 – Meeple and the Moose - […] Martinez Jaramillo, Natalia Rojas, and Beth Sobel, Wingspan was an instant hit. I’ve already talked about how Wingspan is…
  2. Weekly Report, October 26th, 2022 – Meeple and the Moose - […] If you want to read my full thoughts on Wingspan, just click here! […]
  3. Weekly Report – April 26th – Akropolis, Marvel: Remix, and Cat in the Box Deluxe Edition – Meeple and the Moose - […] had the pleasure of joining Ryan Rau on his YouTube channel to play games, Once we played Wingspan (review…
  4. Isle of Trains: All Aboard – Board Game Review – Meeple and the Moose - […] someone does a thing, and everyone benefits. Concordia does this incredibly well, a couple birds in Wingspan benefit all…
  5. Top 5 – Best Board Games to Play with Newbies – Meeple and the Moose - […] Full Review […]
  6. My Top 10 games of 2024 – Meeple and the Moose - […] off the core gameplay mechanics of the massively successful Wingspan, Connie Vogelmann crafted a new game in which players…
  7. Doomlings – Board Game Review – Meeple and the Moose - […] evoke, but Doomlings doesn’t hit the same highs as other tableau building games, such as Wingspan or Race for…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

Perch – Board Game Review

Perch – Board Game Review

Perch is an area control game for 2 to 5 players, designed by Douglas Hettrick, with art by Ari Oliver, and published by Inside Up games in 2025. Perch casts players as a colour of bird and tasks them with earning the most points possible over 5 rounds. Each round players will take two birds of their colour, and pull two more birds out from a bag as their options for the round. Then, turn by turn, players will place one of the birds they control onto the various tiles on the table. Once everyone is done placing their birds, each tile is evaluated for majority. Whoever has the most birds on a tile will earn the top billing of points, but there’s a small catch. Players who have tied amounts of birds will cancel each other out, denying each other from scoring any points at all.

Tearable Quest – Board Game Review

Tearable Quest – Board Game Review

Once upon a time, I was learning about the difference between lived experiences and observed experiences. The teacher split the class in half. One group sat back and recorded what they saw, while the other group had to run up a staircase breathing only through a straw. Then the class switched roles.

Unsurprisingly, the observers didn’t quite grasp how difficult the task really was until they experienced it themselves. And that lesson came back to me when I sat down to play Tearable Quest, designed by Shintaro Ono, with art by Sai Beppu, and published by Allplay in 2025.

3 Witches – Board Game Review

3 Witches – Board Game Review

One of the things I love about trick-taking games is how effortlessly they get to the table. You generally get a deck of cards and deal most if not all the cards out. The teach is usually something along the lines of “It’s a trick-taking game, but here’s the twist…” and you’re off. The bones of trick-taking games are familiar: follow suit, win tricks, claim victory. Sure, each game brings its own little wrinkles that make each one unique and interesting, but the foundations of the games are usually comforting and intuitive.