Book Review – Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir

by | Aug 23, 2023 | Book Reviews, Reviews

Project Hail Mary begins with an amnesiac astronaut waking up in a room with two mummified bodies, and needs to remember who he is and what he’s doing. Turns out, he’s on a space station hurtling through space. Through a series of flashbacks we learn that the hero, Ryland Grace, a high school science teacher, is humanities sole hope in what is surely to be a cataclysmic event causing the end of all life on Earth.

If you’ve read Andy Weir’s previous books (The Martian and Artemis), then you’ll be acquainted with his voice. Each of the characters are plucky, pun-ridden, and sassy, no matter the situation. While Weir’s writing style offers puns, jokes, and pop-culture references that inject levity and fun, they’re shoe-horned into characters in high leadership positions facing humanity ending crises, it just feels wrong in the end.

Photo by Pixabay on Pexels.com


What starts as a space flu stealing the heat from our sun, and expanding to dozens of nearby stars, Project Hail Mary establishes the science that forms the bedrock for the rest of the plot. While the mystical astrophage is fantastical, I like that Weir establishes its properties quickly, then has those properties come back again and again to create unexpected problems for the characters to solve. I also like that it feels like Weir has done his homework, just like in The Martian. The Science feels researched and real, and inspires excitement when a character can take a scientific approach and apply logical steps to their situations.

Project Hail Mary is an approachable hard Sci-Fi, first encounter tale, as it’s filled with optimism. Curiosity and excitement are the main emotions the heroes feel and display, which is great for someone like myself who doesn’t read a lot of Sci-Fi in the first place. I got caught up in the adventure and discovery that Project Hail Mary promised, and I was enraptured when Blip-A first appeared. It never got mired down in fear, war, or politics, as many Sci-Fi books do. Rocky very quickly turned into a snarky human-esqe character instead of an alien with its own personality and culture, I nevertheless enjoyed the ride.

Photo by Pixabay on Pexels.com

The parts that felt contrived were Rocky’s magical material that seemed to be able to fit any situation. On the other hand, I do like that its qualities came back to bite the characters in the ass. Also, once Grace remembered enough about his missions, I felt the flashbacks became unnecessary. It was establishing some of the character qualities that Grace no longer exhibited in the present story. He’s a coward, but he preforms death-defying EVAs without a moment’s hesitation. He’s selfish, but he very quickly sacrifices himself to save his friend. I felt the flashbacks went on just a little too long and near the end, I found myself really wanting to return to the present story.

I enjoyed Project Hail Mary. It was a fun, optimistic adventure, and I recommending it despite my criticisms, especially to anyone who enjoyed the Martian. I don’t think Project Hail Mary will convert those who bounced off Weir’s previous books, but for returning fans, this adventure tickled my love of discovery and was an incredibly fun read.

Related Articles

Re;Act: The Arts of War – Board Game Review

Re;Act: The Arts of War – Board Game Review

Re;Act: The Arts of War is a fast-paced, anime-inspired dueling game where clever card play and tight movement create high-stakes tactical showdowns. Its reaction chain system demands foresight, and each asymmetric character brings fresh challenges. Beautifully produced and deeply rewarding, it’s a must play for fans of head-to-head strategy who crave mastery over mayhem

Forest Shuffle – Board Game Review

Forest Shuffle – Board Game Review

In Forest Shuffle, designed by Kosch, with art by Toni Llobet and Judit Piella, and published by Lookout Games in 2023, players are competing to gather the most valuable trees and attract the best fauna to those trees, creating a mutually beneficial point generating engine.

The Gang – Board Game Review

The Gang – Board Game Review

The Gang, designed by John Cooper and Kory Heath, art by German design studio Fiore GmbH, and published by KOSMOS in 2024, is cooperative poker.