3 Witches – Board Game Review

by | Feb 21, 2026 | Board Game Reviews, Reviews

Disclaimer – A copy of 3 Witches was provided by the designer

One of the things I love about trick-taking games is how effortlessly they get to the table. You generally get a deck of cards and deal most if not all the cards out. The teach is usually something along the lines of “It’s a trick-taking game, but here’s the twist…” and you’re off. The bones of trick-taking games are familiar: follow suit, win tricks, claim victory. Sure, each game brings its own little wrinkles that make each one unique and interesting, but the foundations of the games are usually comforting and intuitive.

3 Witches is not that game.

Or rather, it eventually is. But before you can enjoy the clever little mind games, you need to wrap your head around a teach that feels less like “here’s the twist” and more like “Let me read to you this complex spell from a potion making textbook”

To begin a round of 3 Witches, shuffle the 18-card deck and deal all the cards evenly to three players. Everyone checks their hand and whomever is holding the Elixir card declares that fact. That player doesn’t automatically control the round, though. In fact, they’re now the last player to bid.

Starting with the player to the left of the Elixir holder, they have the option to bid or pass. When it comes to bidding, a player can bid to win either 3 or 4 tricks. If they bid 3 tricks, the subsequent players have an opportunity to bid 4 and take control of the lead position, or pass. Any player who bids 4 tricks automatically ends the bidding round.

Whoever wins the bid becomes the Lead Witch for the round. The other two players form a temporary alliance as the Lesser Witches. The Lead Witch places the bid card in front of them to signify their role. And then the wyrdness begins.

Each trick in 3 Witches is played in a very particular order:

  1. The Lead Witch plays two cards:
    • One face up (this establishes the lead suit)
    • One face down (kept secret for now)
  2. The first Lesser Witch must follow suit if able.
    • If they cannot follow suit, they pass for the moment.
  3. The second Lesser Witch plays a card (following suit if possible).
  4. If the first Lesser Witch had to pass earlier, they now play a card.
  5. The Lead Witch reveals their face-down card.

Now the trick is resolved, but not quite in the usual way. Winning the trick isn’t simply about playing the highest card of the lead suit. 3 Witches uses a small value formula involving the combination of cards played. For example, if two cards of the same suit are involved, they combine their values. The same happens if the two cards played are the same value. If the two cards played are different suits and different numbers, then only the highest value of those cards counts toward determining the winner. Compare the final values, and whoever is higher wins the trick. Also the Lead Witch always wins ties.

It’s clever. It’s quite unintuitive. And the first time you play, everyone will be absolutely glued to their player aids.

After a trick is resolved, the winner gets a bit of control over the tempo of the round.

  • If the Lesser Witches win the trick, they return one of the Lead Witch’s cards to the Lead Witch’s hand.
  • If the Lead Witch wins, they secretly choose one of the two cards they played and return it to their hand face down.

That’s right, the Lead Witches cards cycle back. This mechanism gives 3 Witches its delicious tension. Every trick is not only about winning or losing; it’s about which card you want to reclaim and how that will influence the remaining tricks.

Each round lasts for exactly five tricks, then scoring happens. If the Lead Witch makes their bid exactly (the three or four tricks they called, absolutely no more and no less), then they score 2 points. If the Lead Witch misses their bid, each of the lesser witches score 1 point each.

Then, shuffle, redeal, and start the bidding phase again. The game continues until one player hits 5 points, at which point the coven crowns its leader.

3 Witches is a game of temporary alliances and working together to control the narrative. Because each round is only 5 tricks, and the Lead Witch needs to win 3 or 4 of those tricks, the lesser witches need to work together to force the Lead Witch into losing, or, winning too hard.

I know some people find the phrase “knife fight in a phone booth” to be a cliché and overused way to describe close quarters conflict. So instead, I’ll say that 3 Witches is a fistfight in an elevator. At 18 cards, it’s much easier to count cards and deduce information based on what the other two players have already played. More than once during my plays I was able to path out exactly how I could win a round as a Lead Witch, if, and only if, two specific cards were in the same hand.

There’s a ton of smart design in 3 Witches. From the minute 18 card deck that really encourages players to count cards, to having 5 suits with 3 to 4 cards each, to the player with the elixir being the last one to bid, so much of the game design and rules shows that there has been a lot of thought put into every aspect of this small card game. Everything is so finite, so considered, it’s really an impressive showcase of design work by Corey Young.

Contributing to that “wrestling match in a broom closet” feeling is the fact that each round is only five tricks long. The moment the first trick hits the table and cards start revealing themselves, you can feel the decision space tighten. Your options constrict. Unsettling certainty creeps in. As the Lead Witch, you might struggle to lose even a single trick. At the start of a round you might feel chuffed holding two 5s, but the moment you accidentally scoop a trick you were trying to duck, the panic sets in. Suddenly you’re not trying to win, you’re trying to win precisely.

And that’s where 3 Witches feels most exciting.

The 18-card deck means information moves fast. With so few cards in circulation, you can count, deduce, and sometimes even map out the exact path to victory. More than once I’ve sat there as the Lead Witch thinking, This works… but only if those two specific cards are in the same hand. It becomes much less about hoping and more about calculating.

There’s a ton of smart design packed into this tiny box. Five suits with only three or four cards each. The Elixir holder bidding last. The cycling card mechanism that prevents clean attrition. Everything feels deliberate. Considered. Tight. It’s an impressive showcase of design work by Corey Young. The production by AllPlay is svelte too. A tiny box of cards and 12 cardboard chits makes 3 Witches a game that feels far bigger than its footprint.

I also love how dynamic the table politics feel. The Lead Witch changes every round, which keeps the semi-cooperative tension fresh. Winning as a Lesser Witch feels easier, but in doing so you’re handing a point to a rival. Taking the Lead Witch role is thrilling because you can leap ahead with two points. But if you fail, both of your opponents inch closer to their victory. Every bid feels loaded. Every trick feels consequential.

I really appreciate 3 Witches. I love how sharp it feels, how finite and intentional every decision is. It’s not an effortless teach, and I suspect that the strict three-player count will keep it from ever becoming a universal classic. But in the right setting, with those who enjoy kickboxing in a cardboard box, that is to say, counting cards, weaving in and out of tight margins, and that delicious feeling of trying to thread a needle under pressure, 3 Witches absolutely sings.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

Final Fantasy XII: Revenant Wings

Final Fantasy XII: Revenant Wings

Final Fantasy XII: Revenant Wings is one of the few games in the Final Fantasy Catalogue that I actually played back when it was first released, in late 2007. I didn’t remember much about it, other than that it’s a real-time strategy game on the Nintendo DS and that I had managed to get to the final boss, but never managed to make it over the finish line (much like my Final Fantasy X experience, actually). But being fresh off The Final Fantasy XII: The Zodiac Age means that there will never be a better time than now to play through Revenant Wings, so I buckled down and dug out my old 3DSXL. And besides, I was hopeful that the characters introduced in Zodiac Age would be expanded upon and developed further. I realize now that was a bit of a naive hope.

Sky Team – Board Game Review

Sky Team – Board Game Review

Sky Team, designed by Luc Rémond and published by Scorpion Masqué in 2023 is a two-player cooperative game of limited communication. You and your partner are pilots trying to land a plane. Each of you rolls four dice and keeps them hidden behind your screen. Then, one at a time, you take turns placing the dice in certain areas of your console. Often the the sum of the two dice, one placed by you and one by your partner, will affect different aspects of how the plane flies. The goal of Sky Team is to land safely in the end. That means having no other planes in your way, ensuring your plane isn’t tilted, and touching the ground at a speed that isn’t going to send you hurtling off the end of the runway.

Final Fantasy XII: The Zodiac Age

Final Fantasy XII: The Zodiac Age

It’s been just over a month since I started Final Fantasy XII. This time the gap between starting and finishing wasn’t because I lost interest, like it was with Final Fantasy VIII. It’s because I got a new job, and now I only have about an hour a day to play games. Final Fantasy XII took me roughly 36 hours, and that doesn’t count the time the in-game clock lost when I got a game over and had to reload an old save, nor the fact that I had it on X2 speed almost the entire time.