Sometimes I wonder how much designers end up living in the shadow of their own biggest hits. Does Agricola loom large in the mind of Uwe Rosenberg, affecting everything he touches? Is every new Stefan Feld release inevitably compared to The Castles of Burgundy? And more importantly, do those comparisons subtly shape how designers approach their next projects?

That was my thought that kept creeping in while I was playing Recall, the follow-up from most of the designers of Revive, a game I’ve held in very high regard since it came out. Honestly, it might be my favourite release of the past five years. Recall shares the same artist and overall production aesthetic, which makes the comparison between games almost unavoidable. It looks like Revive’s cousin, and that alone sets certain expectations before you’ve even taken a single turn.

Recall is, at its heart, an action selection game played over just 13 rounds. Each round is a single turn, either sliding one of your action keys into your board and taking the corresponding actions, or taking a recall turn to pull them all back. That recall turn does give you a bit of income based on how many keys you retrieve, but it also costs you something precious: time. Thirteen turns for the game is not a lot, and you feel that constraint almost immediately.

Before even getting into the mechanics, I have to say there’s a really satisfying physicality to the whole production. Slotting a cardboard key into a slot on your board is completely unnecessary from a functional standpoint, but it looks and feels great. It’s satisfying watching the little orange “eye” peek through the keyhole, and it’s a tactile way to represent the actions you’ve already taken. The production doesn’t need to be this elaborate, but I’m very glad that it is.

At the start, your two keys are basic. Actually, they’re totally blank. But pretty quickly you’ll acquire better ones with abilities printed directly on them. So when you take an action, you’re not just doing the action on your board, you also trigger what’s on the key, in whatever order you want. That flexibility is where Recall starts to open up. Suddenly a simple action becomes a small engine, and later, a full-on cascade of actions and benefits.

The actions themselves are fairly straightforward at a glance. You can spawn more meeples on the main board wherever you already have a presence, move groups across the hex map, ferry across connected bodies of water, reveal new tiles, and excavate. Excavation is the big one, the action that feels like five actions rolled into one. It’s also the most mentally taxing at first, because each building you can build requires its own specific terrain. In addition to building, you can excavate, which has you taking stones off the board and paying a variable cost based on the number of stones on that hex, and getting a variable reward based on the number of stones and the colour of the one you’re taking off the board. Thankfully, the player aid is printed right on your board for easy reference.

Interestingly, there’s no real blocking in Recall. You can move freely without interference, which gives the map a more open feel than you might expect, especially if you’re coming in from Revive. That being said, if you do choose to build where someone else already has, you’ll pay an extra meeple for the privilege, and your opponent will get to spawn a meeple there. It sounds punishing, but in practice, at least in my three-player games, it didn’t come up often enough to feel oppressive.

Where Recall really shines is in how it builds toward these sprawling, satisfying turns. Many actions are bundled together, move twice and excavate, or reveal a tile and move and excavate. Then once you start layering in key abilities, clan powers, gadgets, and bonuses from building next to camps on the board, turns can stretch in that delightful, “wait, I can also do this… and then this… and then that lets me do that…” kind of way. It’s not quite a full-blown engine builder, but the combotastic nature of your turns ends up feeling very satisfying, very quickly.

But it’s not all smooth sailing. The map is tight, and movement is more restrictive than I previously alluded to. Water is a hard barrier unless you use the specific ferry action. Then there are the volcanoes, which are a hard barrier, unless you’re playing the one clan that can actually use them. Adding to that are the cubes scattered across the board. You must pick them up when you encounter them, which can disrupt your plans in frustrating ways, as they cost an increasing number of meeples. Hopefully you brought enough along on your movement to continue onto your actual destination and still have enough remaining to complete your building. The compensation for the cubes is often progress on knowledge tracks, which is valuable, but if a cube is in your way, and you’re short on meeples, it feels like a tall wall you can’t get around.

Those knowledge tracks, though, are where Recall gets really interesting. At the start of the game, you draft a clan with a unique ability, often powered by the stones you excavate. You also get a unique gadget, which is essentially a bonus action. As you advance on the knowledge tracks, you’ll unlock additional clans and gadgets, layering more powers into your toolkit. By the end of the game, if you’ve invested heavily, you could be juggling four clans and four gadgets, all with their own abilities. It’s a lot, but in a good way. It creates this sense of growing versatility that I found genuinely exciting. Further to that as you earn points, you automatically upgrade your actions, with each upgrade seeming small, but almost always 50% more powerful.

And all of this is happening under the pressure of those 13 turns. You simply cannot do everything you want to do. The game becomes about stretching each action as far as it will possibly go, like trying to scrape the final bits of peanut butter from an empty jar for that last slice of toast. That tension is excellent, and it makes recalling your keys feel painful. You know you need to do it, but giving up a full turn to reset your board stings a little. The tight 13 turn structure really encourages you to upgrade your actions early to squeeze as much juice out of your remaining actions as possible.

Layered on top of that are the scoring decisions. Three times during the game, you’ll choose between two scoring conditions to amplify for endgame. Everyone scores all base conditions, but the ones you boost can be worth significantly more. The twist is that each choice also gives you immediate income, and inevitably, the worse scoring option for you just so happens to have the income you desperately need right now. Those moments are great. Do you play for the long term, or take the short-term boost to fuel your next few turns? There’s a similar tension with your personal scoring cards. You start with two and eventually have to discard as you approach the end of the game. But the one choose to discard offers you some income as well. Surely the income you need would be on the scoring condition you’d rather give up, right? Again, it’s that same push and pull: what helps me now versus what pays off later?

All of this adds up to a game that feels full of smart, deliberate design choices. It’s tight, but not suffocating. You always have something you can do, but never enough time to do everything you want. It’s a familiar kind of tension, but executed with a lot of finesse. The modularity of the clans and scoring objectives keeps subsequent games fresh and interesting.

If I have a lingering thought, it’s that I’d love to see more clans. There’s 14 in the game, but the system that has you mixing and matching clans practically begs for more. There are also some small oddities, like scoring icons printed on the board that correspond to some of the scoring cards, but not all, which makes me wonder if there’s already room being left for an expansion. But those are just some minor niggles that don’t get in the way of a great game.

The comparisons to Revive are inevitable, and maybe even a little unfair. Recall clearly shares some DNA, but it never felt like it was trying to be Revive at the table. If anything, it feels sharper, more complex and confident than its predecessor. It delivers a satisfying experience of juggling your meagre resources as you stretch yourself for just one more round before succumbing to your recall action. It may look similar, but Recall doesn’t feel overshadowed by Revive. Recall feels distinct, and more importantly, like a game I’d happily come back to on its own terms again and again.