Meeple And the Moose Top 100 Games: 2024 Edition – #20 to #11

by | Mar 27, 2024 | Lists, Top 100 2024

Almost to the end of the list now! These games are ones that I would play anytime, anywhere. These would always get a resounding “YES” from me, if ever asked to play

20 – Crokinole

Previous Rank: 69

My favourite thing about Crokinole:

It’s one of the most satisfying dexterity games I’ve ever played. There’s a high skill ceiling, but also great potential for laugh out loud funny moments. From bouncing off two of your opponents disks to land in the centre, to fully missing the most basic of shots.

19 – Sagrada

Previous Rank: 13 | Full Review

My favourite thing about Sagrada:

The translucent colourful dice are simply beautiful, and when beautiful components are paired with a simple yet satisfying puzzle, you get a perfect introductory game. I cannot tell you how many people I’ve convinced to start playing board games regularly when I see them doing a Sudoku, and I give them a nudge into the hobby with Sagrada.

18 – Brass: Birmingham

Previous Rank: 28

My favourite thing about Brass: Birmingham:

The positive player interaction. One player builds a coal or iron mine, another player consumes it to build something else, both players benefit. That on top of some really interesting dynamics make Brass: Birmingham a top tier game.

17 – Orleans

Previous Rank: 19

My favourite thing about Orleans:

The quintessential bag-building game for me. I love the engine that you get to build, and pulling the characters you need out of a bag is exciting!

16 – Scythe

Previous Rank: 9 | Full Review

My favourite thing about Scythe:

Oh man, it’s a shorter list to say what I don’t love about Scythe. To pick one thing that really draws me into this game, I love that it’s a ‘cold-war’ game. The threat of combat is so much more present than the actual combat. I’ve had games where I was the loser of the only combat encounter of the whole game, but I ended up as the overall winner. It sounds counterintuitive, I know, but it’s endlessly satisfying.

15 – The Castles of Burgundy

Previous Rank: 15 | Full Review

My favourite thing about The Castles of Burgundy:

My favourite Stefan Feld game by far. I love how simple each turn is, just use your two dice, but how efficently you use your actions determines how well you do in the game. There’s a push to fill your small provinces early to get the bonus points for doing so, but those large provinces offer huge rewards, if you can complete them. One day, I want to complete the whole board. I don’t know if it’s possible, but it’s what I want to do.

14 – Calico

Previous Rank: 86 | Full Review

My favourite thing about Calico:

Oh gosh, Calico is a puzzle game with teeth, and I love it for it. Every hex you place feels impactful, and deciding to put a purple dots tile in one spot means you’re choosing to not pursue three other objectives with that spot. I have my head in my hands the entire time I’m playing Calico, which doesn’t sound like a good thing, but I love the burn this game gives my brain

13 – Burgle Bros.

Previous Rank: 11 | Full Review

My favourite thing about Burgle Bros.

The thematic gameplay, of course! Burgle Bros is the only game where I demand a soundtrack from a heist movie is playing during the game.

12 – Istanbul

Previous Rank: 5 | Full Review

My favourite thing about Istanbul

Leaving a trail of workers behind and then doubling back to pick them up again is a genius mechanic. You want to be efficient with your actions, and spending time going back to a space you don’t need is painful, but running out of workers means you can’t do anything. I also love how fast Istanbul is to play, with most games taking around ~25 actions, you can fly through games, assuming no one is stalling at the market for too long.

11 – Isle of Skye: From Chieftain to King

Previous Rank: 4 | Full Review | Expansion Review

My favourite thing about Isle of Skye:

The auction/bidding mechanic that makes money flow around the table, and the game constantly pouring more and more money into the economy letting the bids grow bigger and more ludicrous makes for exciting rounds. I love pricing one tile just a bit too high and watching my opponents agonize over spending that much cash on a single tile. I don’t even care if I win, I just want my friends to be uncomfortable for a bit!

Previous List: 30 – 21

Next list: 10 – 1

0 Comments

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Meeple And the Moose Top 100 Games: 2024 Edition – #30 to #21 – Meeple and the Moose - […] Next List: 20 – 11 […]
  2. Meeple And the Moose Top 100 Games: 2024 Edition – #10 to #1 – Meeple and the Moose - […] Previous List: #20 – #11 […]
  3. Quilts & Cats of Calico – Meeple and the Moose - […] already reviewed Calico back in 2021, and if you’ve followed along my Top 100 games list (2024 edition) you…
  4. Expeditions – Board Game Review – Meeple and the Moose - […] released in 2023 debuted as the sequel to 2016’s Scythe, which is fairly high on my favourite games of…
  5. My Top 10 games of 2024 – Meeple and the Moose - […] site (yet), I’ve touched on how much I enjoy Brass: Birmingham as it sits at number 18 in my…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

Kronologic: Paris 1920 – Board Game Review

Kronologic: Paris 1920 – Board Game Review

Last week I wrote about Turing Machine, a deduction puzzle that fascinated me with its cardboard computer but ultimately left me a little cold with the multiplayer experience. This week I’m talking about designers Fabien Gridel and Yoann Levet’s follow-up game, Kronologic: Paris 1920. It turns out the same designers have taken some of those clever ideas and turned them into something that feels much more like a game you’d actually want to sit down and play with other people.

Why do People Rate Games a “1”?

Why do People Rate Games a “1”?

Why do people give a game a 1 on BoardGameGeek?

It’s a question I’ve been mulling over for years, and one that tends to pop into my head whenever I’m browsing an upcoming release and trying to get a sense of what people are thinking. I scroll past the preview images, maybe skim a few comments, and then my eyes drift over to the rating… only to see that bar graph with a giant foot, the 1 ratings outnumbering every other number by a large margin. Also, why the heck are there ratings on this game if it isn’t even out yet? These 1s aren’t low scores from disappointed players, they aren’t thoughtful critiques explaining why something didn’t land. These 1s feel more of a punishment than anything else. And I always find myself wondering: what is that number actually trying to say?

Turing Machine – Board Game Review

Turing Machine – Board Game Review

I’ve always had a soft spot for puzzle games. From Tetris to those logic puzzles you find in the Penny Press game books, to word games and Sudoku puzzles. I love the moment when I sit down in front of one, utterly clueless, then start teasing at the edges, working the system to slowly unravel the answer.